Photographs, Photographers and Photography

October 31, 2008

Canon – you need to fix your glass

Filed under: Lenses — Thomas Pindelski @ 7:41 am

Simply unacceptable color fringing.


5D, 50mm f/1.4 at f/8 – after and before correcting for green and red chromatic aberration

When processing the picture included in yesterday’s journal entry, I was reminded again of the truly frightful extent of uncorrected chromatic aberration (color fringing) in Canon’s 50mm f/1.4 standard lens. For many this is a portrait lens on cropped sensor bodies, with an equivalent focal length of 80mm.

The picture on the right is unprocessed, straight from the camera at the lens’s sweet spot of f/8. The one on the left is after removing the chromatic aberration using the sliders in Lightroom. Even in these small pictures the amount of chromatic aberration is shocking – these enlarged snaps would make for a 30″ x 20″ print. (The small scale difference results from correcting converging verticals in Photoshop CS2).

Given the superb quality of the sensors in Canon’s DSLRs, isn’t it about time that some more attention was paid to fixing dated lens designs like the fixed focal length 50mm one? This sort of thing has been properly designed by any number of manufacturers decades ago and there really is no excuse for such poor optical engineering in a medium priced fixed focal length lens who many, suspicious of the bulk and poor optics in most zooms, still regard as their ’standard’ lens. Especially old duffers like me who toured the world with a 50mm or 35mm on our cameras, because that’s all we could afford.

Now a glance at any news source will confirm that there are more complaining historians in the world than people with fix-it ideas. The fix here could not be simpler, or more lucrative for all concerned. Do a Panasonic. License Leica’s fabulous designs, Canon, forget about corporate pride, and make sure the final product is emblazoned with the Leica name. Use your mass manufacturing genius to drive the price down and I will be the first to have a fully automated 50mm f/2 Summicron-R Leica lens (made by Canon) on my wonderful 5D – the best 50mm lens ever made. Heck, if I’m feeling spendy I’ll even consider springing for the 50mm Summilux-R with its f/1.4 maximum speed – the second greatest 50mm lens ever made. And while Leica, 40 years on, still cannot manage to add autofocus to its SLR lenses, for Canon that would, of course, be de rigeur.

And while you are at it, Canon, feel free to replace your underwhelming 20mm f/2.8 (which I know and dislike) with Leica’s superb 19mm f/2.8 Elmarit-R, or even with the older 21mm f/4 Super Angulon-R which I knew and loved for many years. Leica and Schneider conspired on that design – can life get any better than that?


A big enlargement to make things yet clearer – color fringes before correction

October 28, 2008

A bargain and a classic

Filed under: 5D — Thomas Pindelski @ 7:54 am

The first classic of the digital age

The Canon 5D was the first camera to bring semi-affordable full frame sensors to digital photographers and, I believe, will go down as one of the great classics of the early digital photography age, much as, say, medium format was defined by the Rolleiflex and 35mm film by the rangefinder Leica. The leap in image quality it offered from 35mm and the ability to regularly match medium format film for definition and detail with none of the pain of operation make it the greatest camera design of its time.

The new 5D Mark II is slated to arrive in the US around December and yet there is already a slew of lightly used 5D Mark I models for sale on the web. Maybe it’s the economy, but I would think the price will soften further once Mark II generates some serious upgrade volume.

Check the eCrook (aka eBay) site and you will see that completed auctions average about $1,300 for a mint condition lightly used body.

But I want the 21+ megapixel sensor in the new 5D Mark II, I hear you say, which begs the question why?

Do you propose making prints larger than 24″ x 30″? Do you want to use the movie mode? Is cleaning the dust off the sensor a real pain? Well, if you answered Yes to these, you may need the Mark II. No one else does.


Two classics – Canon 5D and Leica M3

October 24, 2008

American Monument

Filed under: Book reviews — Thomas Pindelski @ 1:44 pm

Really, really Big.

‘Really, really Big’. Thus starts the introduction to this book of photographs by Lynn Davis, authored by Witold Rybczynski. Rybczynski’s 4 page introduction is alone worth the price of admission to this book, which features pictures of American Monuments – be they gas stations or the Lincoln Memorial – all in gently printed monochrome. The whole production reeks of class and presents the viewer with subtle images which let you do the thinking. Not that common in photo books where the images frequently scream for attention.

If your interests include architecture and fine photography then there is every reason to own this beautifully made book.

October 15, 2008

Afternoon languor

Filed under: Photographs — Thomas Pindelski @ 12:26 pm

Warm sun.

This is the sort of thing I can never resist. Warm sun, old bricks (note the earthquake reinforcing plates – this can only be California!) and one of the very best lenses ever made at any price.


5D, 200mm f/2.8 ‘L’, 1/8000, f/4, ISO 400

Bistro Laurent really has no business being a world class restaurant in a hick town like Paso Robles, but there it is and the food is to die for! Scan the wine list and you will find the Zinfandel wine made from my grape crop – it’s the Peachy Canyon Winery “Especial” 2004 – if you are lucky your local store may have some left, but that’s a long shot as the crop is small and the wine sells out quickly.

October 14, 2008

Seeing Gardens

Filed under: Book reviews — Thomas Pindelski @ 9:09 am

A fine collection by a master photographer.

Few artificial creations can equal the joy of a beautiful garden. And while Americans, as a whole, care little for lovely gardens – witness the bare minimum handkerchief of grass and a few tired drought resistant plants so common here – Sam Abell shows that beauty is to be found if you look, and Abell has been doing that with an expert’s eye for decades. And you don’t get published regularly in National Geographic for nothing.

I find the Japanese approach, which sees the garden as a thing of spiritual beauty, much preferable to the America minimum cost/dress-it-for-sale version. Or, for that matter, brown lawns decorated with beer cans in all those tract homes and subdivisions bought and lost by fraudsters, whom we will all be bailing out these next few years.

At last count my garden of some two acres had four lawns, three olive trees and some fifty other trees, both fruit bearing and decorative, and while I work mightily to keep it looking just so, it cannot compare to even the worst picture in this fine book.

If you like lovely gardens and landscapes beautifully rendered, with a serious hint of Eliot Porter thrown in, you will like this book. At $5.95 mine is a Depression Era special, rivaling the cost of a Big Mac and fries with none of the health implications. (Disclosure: I am long MacDonald’s stock – they may serve poisonous garbage but health and morality have nothing to do with stock selection).

October 12, 2008

In the Shadow of the Moon

Filed under: Photographs — Thomas Pindelski @ 10:55 am

What America needs now.

It seems oddly fitting that this past Friday, the culmination of Wall Street’s (and America’s) worst week ever, that a friend should have sent me In the Shadow of the Moon, a NASA documentary about the twelve men who have walked on the surface of the moon.

In these digital days it’s hard to recall that the still photography gear used by these brave men was nothing more than a Hasselblad 500EL or two fitted with a long roll film magazine and upgraded with some low temperature lubricants to make sure nothing froze up. Americans, as cavalier with the environment as ever, concluded that it would be cheaper to dump the bodies on the moon than to bring them back to earth. Indeed, in the 1970s, the Victor Hasselblad company ran a classic advertising campaign pointing out that Hasselblads, lightly used, were to be had free. All you needed was a round trip to the lunar surface to get yours.

In this documentary you can see various moon walkers banging away with their 500ELs, a large digital counter clearly visible on the right side of the film magazine to remind them how many of their 200 shots they had used.


The Hasselblad 500EL model used by the moon walkers

This film has some so-so movie pictures (the technology of small movie cameras really was pretty mediocre back in 1969) and some tremendous still pictures. These astrophysicists, mechanical engineers and scientists, passing for astronauts, were so elevated by a shared spirit of ecstasy in their journey that their photographic skills rose magically to a new plane as the whole world rooted for America to pull off the Apollo 11 landing.

While most know of the great snap Armstong took of Aldrin, Armstong’s figure reflected in Aldrin’s face mask, there are two special moments that caught my attention. One is a movie frame showing the blast off of the lunar lander on its way to dock with the orbital module before returning to earth. I had never seen this and remember well the feeling of dread that there was only one chance to get this right. As the lander blasts off, the American flag in the lunar surface rocks mightily on its pole but remains standing. It is an immensely moving moment.


The Apollo lunar lander blasts off from the lunar surface, Old Glory in the blast

The other, also a movie picture, is easily the most beautiful and heart warming in the whole movie. For all their protestations about the beauty of the lunar surface, there is no disguising that the orb of earth from space is a very special thing, and the moment the parachutes deploy in a superb aerial shot, we are all united as one race sharing our adulation of this most perfect of places. This still frame does not begin to do that magical moment justice.


Apollo 11 returns to earth

On a broader scale, the Apollo program reminds us how strong leadership can inspire a nation and the world. The astronauts speak eloquently of their reception worldwide pointing out that, wherever they go, they are greeted with the words “We did it”. That sounds right. The greatest, most generous nation on earth did not seek to keep this to itself but wanted to share its joy and wide eyed spirit of discovery with the world.

Another point to note is the life changing effect the moon trips had on all concerned. Most speak eloquently and mystically of the experience and while logical thinkers will continue extolling Darwinian evolution over creationism, when you see that orb of blue and white approaching, well, you do tend to think of some sort of Supreme Being because it seems too perfect to maybe just have happened.

This is a special piece of film and photography and a recommended antidote to a period in which America’s bleeding is infecting the whole world. American hegemony may be fading, who knows?, but I have yet to encounter anyone, no matter how anti-American, who would argue that a world lead by the Chinese would be a better place.

October 10, 2008

Lunch on Wall Street

Filed under: Photographs — Thomas Pindelski @ 5:39 pm

Past is prologue.


(Former) Masters of the Universe line up for lunch. Photographer unknown


The week that was

October 9, 2008

Jeff Mermelstein

Filed under: Book reviews — Thomas Pindelski @ 10:42 am

Funny and in color!

So many photography books take themselves so seriously that it’s always a pleasure to come across one that is not only very funny, but is also in glorious, over-processed, high contrast color. All of which works well in this droll piece of work by Jeff Mermelstein.

Many of the candid pictures in ‘No Title Here’ are taken at places where people gather – shopping malls, beach parties, receptions – and Mermelstein’s eye is both incredibly fast and ever sardonic, with nary a hint of nastiness (the sort of thing that is constantly ‘in your face’ in the work of Robert Frank, for example).

$10 from your usual remaindered books place or even less from eBay’s Half.com – thanks to a reader for the tip. Much as I detest eBay’s questionable sales and business practices, a book is a book is a book, and a cheap book is always better.

October 8, 2008

Tattoo You

Filed under: Photographs — Thomas Pindelski @ 4:42 pm

The body as canvas.


5D, 24-105 at 105mm, 1/90, f/4.5, ISO 125

This man was painting the most exquisite curlicues and decorations – using a very sharp-edged brush – on the back of a rather tired old VW squareback which someone obviously loved very much. He noticed me admiring his work so I asked if I might take a snap of his tattoed body.

He was only too pleased to oblige and struck this classically dignified pose without any direction from me.

October 7, 2008

The Carnegie Library

Filed under: Photographs — Thomas Pindelski @ 10:52 am

The idea of a great man.


Paso Robles Carnegie Library, built in 1908. 5D, 24-105 at 105mm, 1/500, f/6.7, ISO200

It’s said that the true measure of philanthropy is not how much you give but how much you have left. By that measure, Andrew Carnegie (1835-1919) is the greatest philanthropist the world has seen, having given away almost all of his fortune at the time of his death. Inflation makes comparisons difficult, but if you figure wealth as a percentage of Gross National Product, Carnegie ranks fifth in America, after Rockefeller, Vanderbilt, Astor and Girard (d. 1831 – trade and banking).

Carnegie mostly gave his money to build public libraries in the United States, England and his native Scotland. While I see libraries as essentially a waste of real estate in a digital world (the Library of Congress could be digitized for $1 billion, the space put to better use) there is an undeniable charm to a fine library and the tactile enjoyment of good books.

The small town of Paso Robles, a stone’s throw from my home in Templeton in central California, has a pretty town square graced with a Carnegie Library. Sadly, the brick building was damaged in the earthquake a few years ago and the City has finally come around to fixing the damage. While the whole is still surrounded with chain-link fencing, it’s possible to see the results of the rebuilding from a distance.

Many would denigrate Carnegie for his use of low paid labor in his steel mills near Pittsburgh. To me, the choices are simple. You take one or two generations of the poor and stupid, exploit them horribly and confer a priceless gift on the world. The next generation now has no excuse for being either poor or stupid. Or you do nothing and the poor and stupid continue being just that. It’s your choice, but there’s little arguing with the benefits of the Carnegie way.

A great man and a beautiful piece of architecture. More as the building reaches completion. Check out the brand, spanking new copper piping in the snap above. Gorgeous.

Except for a very small tweak in Photoshop to fix perspective, the picture has had no post processing.

October 5, 2008

Desolate

Filed under: Photographs — Thomas Pindelski @ 2:41 pm

All alone

From my recent one man show.


Swings at Cayucos Beach. Crown Graphic 4×5, 135mm Xenar, Verichrome

October 4, 2008

No Smoking

Filed under: Book reviews — Thomas Pindelski @ 10:28 am

Pure joy.

The undistilled, unalloyed pleasure of a new book is one that remains a perennial source of excitement. But until now I confess I have never opened a book with such an immense grin on my face as this one.

You see, the whole thing looks like a giant carton of cigarettes and you have to find the peel strip on the cellophane to get into the book – just like opening a pack. Then when you finally get the wrapper off, the book emerges from the box in much the same way a cigarette would. Brilliant!

Let’s get the moralizing out of the way, first. In no way is this piece remotely adulatory of one of the more dangerous drugs around. However, it’s a free country and if you want to smoke go ahead. I own cigarette stocks now and then so have at it. Your lungs are my dividend. Just don’t blow the smoke in my direction or exhale in my home.

This book is all about how cigarettes were the glamor accessory over much of the twentieth century in Western culture, especially in the movies. It also shows pictures of how tobacco became increasingly demonized as that century drew to a close and how inept the advertising to curb consumption of the addiction that is nicotine really was.

The photographs span the century as do the many graphic illustrations and there’s something for everyone her – great photography, skilled drawings, exceptional advertising. Too bad that the frisson one gets from peeling the cellophane wrapper can be enjoyed but once!

And when you have had enough, rush out and get Thank you for Smoking with the wonderful Aaron Eckhart as the tobacco industry lobbyist who could sell cigarettes to a terminal lung cancer victim. Wonderfully acted and very on topic for our image obsessed and sound bite fixated society with its negligible attention span.

October 3, 2008

Harvest time!

Filed under: Photographs — Thomas Pindelski @ 9:38 am

An annual ritual.

The crew arrives at 6:30. It’s still dark.

For $7 an hour these great people work insanely hard and by noon we will have twenty of these bins containing 10 tons of the finest Zinfandel grapes in the world; the area where I live – the Templeton Gap in Central California – is renowned for its Zinfandel varietals above all else.

Then the vines will gracefully shed their leaves, the crew will return to prune them to a nub and another growing cycle is complete.

So, I find myself wondering, as a great American farmer, where’s my government subsidy?


A final check of Brix (sugar content)

The wine grower is required, by contract, to provide grapes with a certain Brix level – 25 to 28 for Zinfandel. I’m at 26.5 which is just about right. The tool in the picture is a refractometer, a nice optical device as old as Sir Isaac Newton. A drop of grape juice on the lens, a peek through the eyepiece and Brix is determined.

Back to the regular topics tomorrow. Now please excuse me, I have to go tread on some grapes….

October 2, 2008

Regina Relang

Filed under: Book reviews — Thomas Pindelski @ 8:16 am

A fine German fashion photographer.

The words “wit” and “photography” are rare companions when the photographer in question is German, but Regina Relang is an honorable exception to the rule that has it that humor has yet to be discovered in Germany.


The Elegant World of Regina Relang, by Esther Ruelfs

Relang’s career spans the immediately pre- and post-WW2 periods, the latter perhaps the greatest outpouring of great fashion and photography we have yet seen.

Her oeuvre is both light hearted and witty and never less than totally sophisticated. And while many of her German models look as if someone took a floor brush to them to reveal a new layer of perfect, unblemished epidermis – what else to expect of the Master Race? – that detracts little from the charm and beauty of her photography.

The book is frustratingly written in both German and (stodgy) English, with the English version in very light print on a light background (conspiracy theorists can have at it here) but as it’s the only monograph out there on Relang, I’m going to button my lip. No book on photography should have a ‘must read’ text and this one certainly more than espouses that dictum. The writing, or maybe it’s the translation, is beyond pedantic.


Wit, class and sophistication. Suzy Parker photographed by Regina Relang, Berlin, 1954.

Relang was also a fine photographer in the more general sense and a selection of her non-fashion work is also on display here. Some of her later work is in color and she has as fine a sense for a simple color palette as she does for monochrome.

A few points of technical interest. Reading between the lines I conclude that Relang was mostly a Rollei twin lens reflex user. What makes this remarkable is that while the small size and low weight of the Rollei liberated the camera from the studio, nothing could suit a waist level Rollei less well than Relang’s style. Relang, you see, was all about motion and action, movement blur and so on. If you have ever tried using a TLR Rollei to follow action (in her time the eye level frame finder was not yet available, being introduced on later models) you will know why I say this. It’s near impossible as the image in the viewfinder is reversed.

Unlike her contemporaries Avedon and Penn, who typically adopt an “everything must be sharp” style, it is rare to find a Relang picture which does not use selective focus. The varied use of this technique in the many pictures in this book speaks to a very high level of technical skill on the part of the photographer. With the depth of field equivalent to a 75 or 80mm lens on a 35mm camera, (but with the field of view of a standard lens), selective focus is easily available at larger apertures, of course.

I highly recommend this book for anyone interested in beautiful photography, gorgeous women, haute couture or great technique.

In my case that’s all of the above.

Don’t waste your money at Amazon – get a remaindered copy. Mine ran $20 from Edward G. Hamilton.

October 1, 2008

Gertrude Käsebier

Filed under: Photographers — Thomas Pindelski @ 7:48 am

A great American photographer.

I’m certainly no fan of filmy, soft focus, photography on the whole, but that’s not to say I don’t like it when it’s well done.

Gertrude Käsebier (1852 – 1934) was an American photographer who did most of her best work around the beginning of the twentieth century. Her work is distinguished by soft light and great warmth and charm.


Portrait Miss N. 1903


Portrait by window light. Date unknown

It’s unclear whether the general fuzziness of her work is the result of poor technique, deliberate manipulation or simply caused by the technical limitations of the time. No matter, the results work.

I was reminded of Käsebier’s work when fellow photographer Leigh Sheldon sent me a recent picture very much in the Käsebier style:


Your light. 2008.

How Leigh got that effect with the birds I do not know, but I would rather it remained a secret. It works better that way.

While the standard writing on Käsebier is that she was a member of the Photo Secession movement headed by Stieglitz, stylistically she was very much her own person.

A timely reminder that not all that is sharp is good, and that not all that is blurred is bad. And it can still be done well today plus, I can assure you, Sheldon’s technique lacks for nothing.

Powered by WordPress