Sharpness – film scans vs. digital files

Forget film if you want ultimate resolution.



Test target, SOOC. Leica M10, 35mm f/2 Canon LTM at f/8.

Using the very sharp Canon 35mm f/2 LTM lens at f/8 and an iPhone I photographed my local ‘test target’ using four delivery methods:

Here are the results showing 100% enlargements in LRc, which means the equivalent of a 72″x48″ print.

JPG film scan:




TIF film scan:




iPhone:




Leica M10:



Click the image for an even larger version at 200%.

The conclusions are obvious, even using a small display device. Want to waste your money and get the scan fast? Speedy ePhoto is for you. Want the best possible TIF scans but with a gargantuan file size then The Film Developing.Co is good and the turnaround is 24 hours from receipt of your film. Want even better results from a pocket device? The iPhone is splendid and I would bet that current versions are better still. But if you want to blow the doors completely off there’s only once choice. A big digital sensor, be it Leica, Nikon, Canon or Sony.

Want resolution? Forget film.